The history of sales methodologies
Every few years, a new sales method is launched as the answer to everything. Barrett traced selling methods back 200 years to see which ones were really new, which ones work, and why.
What we found
Most “new” sales methods are repackaged versions of approaches developed decades ago. In Barrett’s analysis, the only real revolution came in 1968, with Needs Satisfaction Selling at Xerox. For the first time, customers and salespeople sat on the same side of the table and talked about what the customer actually wanted.
Almost everything since, from Strategic and Consultative Selling to Relationship and Solutions Selling, builds on that shift. Some recent methods even bring back the control-based tactics of the late 1800s under a new name.
200 years of sales methods
Each method, when it appeared, the thinking behind it, and who developed or popularised it. The 1968 turning point is highlighted.
| Selling method | Period | Underlying philosophy | Developed by / associated with |
|---|---|---|---|
| Snake Oil Selling | 1800s | Exaggerate and misrepresent to get the business | Former peddlers, commercial travellers |
| Pyramid Selling | 1886 | Identify key decision makers and use them to introduce other prospects | Patterson, NCR |
| Trust Based Selling | 1916 | Improve the profession’s image by building trust | DM Barrett, Patterson, World Sales Congress |
| Scientific Selling | 1916 | Use phrenology to identify prime prospects | World Sales Congress, phrenologists |
| Mood Selling | 1920s | Use emotion to persuade customers to buy | American Bible Society, insurance companies |
| The Fuller Brush Men | 1920 | Focus on people, helping the sales teams | The Fuller Brush Company |
| Psychological Selling | 1930 | Learn to understand what makes buyers tick | Dale Carnegie, Ford Motor Company |
| Barrier Selling | 1930s | Get prospects to say “yes” often enough to be trapped | Peter J Wosh |
| SELL | 1940–1950 | A tell-sell process leading the customer to a commitment | Retail industry, USA |
| ADAPT | 1940–1950 | Pseudo-technical jargon to keep buyers intrigued | Unknown |
| ARC | 1940–1950 | Cross-selling and up-selling in retail | Richard S Tedlow |
| Formula / AIDA Selling | 1950s | The same fixed approach for Attention, Interest, Desire and Action | Unknown |
| Needs Satisfaction Selling | 1968 | A seven-step process to uncover needs and introduce benefits | Don Hamalian, Xerox Corporation |
| Strategic Selling | 1970s | A fixed planning process to find danger areas and penetrate the decision-making process | Miller Heiman |
| Consultative Selling | 1980s | In-depth questioning to understand customer pain, helping buyers see the impact for themselves | Neil Rackham |
| Relationship Selling | 1990s | Strong, trust-based relationships that encourage buyers to commit | Mike Bosworth |
| Solutions Selling | 2000 | Working with customers to agree the solution that fits best | Unknown |
| Challenger Sale | 2011 | Challenge customers to think differently while controlling the sales process | The Corporate Executive Board |
| Selling Better | 2017+ | Ethical and human-centred, underpinned by a practical sales philosophy | Selling Better Movement (Barrett Consulting Group) |
Source: Barrett, The History of Sales Methodologies – why some work and others don’t. See the full table, including how salespeople behaved in each era.
What it means for you today
Judge the method by the buyer
Ask whether a method helps customers make a better decision, or just helps the seller control the sale.
Skills beat scripts
Questioning, listening, planning and integrity outlast any branded process.
Integrity is the constant
Whichever method you use, it works when it’s guided by integrity and a fair exchange of value.
The History of Sales Methodologies – why some work and others don’t
Barrett’s 28-page whitepaper covers each method in detail, including what salespeople did in each era and why some approaches work better than others.